Kos - Iowa: What a Crappy Way to Pick a Candidate

by: wvblueguy

Wed Jan 02, 2008 at 19:45:13 PM EST

I passed on my thoughts regarding the Caucus system in Iowa yesterday. Markos analyzed the caucus system in Iowa in about as thorough manner as possible. You can read what he says here.

The Bluefield Daily Telegraph put an OP ED piece by Dale McFeatters on their editorial page that also bemoaned the emphasis put on Iowa.  That can be read in its entirety after the jump.

I put the whole column here as it is not part of the Bluefield paper's normal on line edition and is part of their "E Edition" that requires registration.

And the point is...
 Exactly what does the Iowa caucus prove?

What the caucus is doing is electing delegates to a later county convention, which in turn chooses delegates for a district convention, then the state convention and finally the national presidential nominating convention by which time Iowa has been all but forgotten.
 
The Iowa presidential caucuses have become such an accepted part of the political calendar it’s easy to forget what bizarre rituals they are.
  But on 6:30 Thursday, if turnout is as expected, 150,000 Iowa Democrats and 80,000 Republicans will gather in public libraries and church basements in 1,784 precincts to propel one or more of a dozen possible candidates to their party’s nomination. Or not. Some years, like 2004 and 2000, it works. Other times it doesn’t.
  The numbers are only a fraction of the Iowa electorate and an infinitesimal percentage of the national electorate, and, being disproportionately over 55 and female, unrepresentative of both. There’s some concern that given easy residency and ID requirements the results might be affected by the hundreds of out-of-state campaign workers in Iowa.
  But like little Peterkin and the famous battle, everybody says the caucuses are important, so they are.
  The two parties’ caucuses operate by slightly different rules, with the Democrats’ predictably being more com plicated.
  The Democratic rules for caucus chairs run to 13 pages.
  Straw polls are taken with candidates required to get at least 15 percent of the vote to be considered “viable.” Failing that, “supporters of nonviable candidates have the option to join a viable candidate group, join another nonviable candidate group to become viable, join other groups to form an uncommitted group or chose to go nowhere and not be counted.” And all that has to be done within 30 minutes.
  Iowans are serious about their civic duties but they’re not going to take all night performing them.
  The caucus chair then multiplies the number of members in each preference group times the number of delegates allotted that precinct and divides by the number of eligible attendees at the cau cus. The candidate with the most dele gates wins — sort of.
  What the caucus is doing is electing delegates to a later county convention, which in turn chooses delegates for a dis trict convention, then the state conven tion and finally the national presidential nominating convention by which time Iowa has been all but forgotten.
  One other thing: The choice of candi date is nonbinding on the delegate.
  The chair is instructed to adjourn the caucus with, “Thank you all for coming.”
  And we do thank you. We think.
  — Dale McFeatters Scripps Howard News Service