West Virginia Blue
The Best Blogging Community in West Virginia
Democratic politics, progressive policies, the good life and free living in Wild, Wonderful West Virginia.
Big Daddy Sen. Robert C. Byrd

Time to end a boycott of Walmart?

by: Clem Guttata

Wed Dec 31, 2008 at 09:05:03 AM EST


In 2008, we had another Walmart open here in the Eastern Panhandle. This one appears from a distance to be a super-humongous version with everything from turnips to tables to tractors. (I haven't set foot inside, so I don't know for sure.)

Over at OpenLeft, Eating Liberally Food For Thought writer Kerry Trueman asks a question worth periodically revisiting, "Should We Shop At Wal-Mart?"

Here's an extended version of the question:

I used to shop at Wal-Mart, until I figured out that low prices based on lousy labor practices and shoddy made-in-China schlock are not such a bargain. But now that Wal-Mart--America's largest food retailer--has jumped on the organic bandwagon, it's making organic products available to folks who lack the access or means to shop at farmers' markets or, say, Whole Foods. Wal-Mart has also made a great show of going green, and just shelled out more than $352 million in what may be the "largest settlement ever for lawsuits over wage violations. ... Is it OK to advocate shopping there if it's the only way you can get your hands on organic stuff (even if it's industrial organic)?

The entire post is well worth a read. You'll learn a lot about the organic foods and why what you get at Walmart is not quite the same as what you get elsewhere.

Some considerations:

Wal-Mart is so huge that it's easy to make the argument that any "good" thing Wal-Mart does - from stocking organic food to changing to energy-saving lightbulbs - makes a huge impact. And in a sense, that is absolutely true. But its potential to make a huge positive impact in one arena can't be viewed in isolation from its potential to hugely screw things up in other arenas. Looking at the sum total seems to be the only way to answer that question fairly.

Fair enough. And what does that sum total look like? On organic... Walmart's relentless pursuit of low prices is inconsistent with the spirit of organic. In the process of offering organic products, they are undermining the standards for organic production and giving consumers a lower quality product than many assume they are purchasing. In other arenas... Walmart's labor and supplier practices are largely unchanged.

For me, I'm still boycotting the Walmart in 2009.

What do you think? Is shopping at Walmart consistent with progressive values?

Clem Guttata :: Time to end a boycott of Walmart?
Tags: , , , , (All Tags)
Print Friendly View Send As Email
Since Sam died nothing can convince me to shop at the store that shall remain nameless (0.00 / 0)
I used to make an exception and pop in on for last minute stocking stuffers for St. Nicholas Day, 6 December. I think the news in 2003 of hiring of undocumented aliens, with Eastern European last names, was the last straw for me.

I read the OpenLeft post last night myself. The argument that the price pressure that W@!M@&# puts on "organic" makes the farmers cut corners was persuasive. The example of Horizon getting the dairy contract, and how their cows are not pastured and grass fed, bolstered my resolve. They think the DFH community is teh stoopid.

In the beginning, employees shared in the company success with stock grants. I admire the business model of just-in-time inventory that turns merchandise around in 3 days on the 30 day float. The figure about how much each super store, employing 200 workers but costing the state around $2100 per worker in subsidies for low income assistance, was the nail in the coffin. W@!M@&# is now the suck.

When Sam started W@!M@&# it was to save the Arkansas shirt manufacturer. Now they are one of the 18 families behind repealing the Paris Hilton [estate] tax. The company mission has gone from Buy American to Fund My Trust Baby. If by progressive you mean making progress for the American worker's share of the bounty that is America, and opposing the growing influence of corporations, I say FAIL.

NFTT: Support My Team or I Will Dance


boycotting Walmart (4.00 / 1)
I don't care how "green" Walmart becomes.  Huge corporations are decimating the economy and culture of communities all over the country.

Samll businesses are going under with  unprecedented speed due to people shopping with these nonentity behemoths.  The money they spend goes into corporate coffers at some distant location, never to return to the communities that spent the money with them, other than the pittance they pay to locally hired people.

Its not just Walmart. Its hardware, books, clothing.  The list goes on and on.  I have decided to shop only locally.  If I can't get it that way, then I will do without.

Yes, I might have to spend a little more intially, but if enough people vowed to shop local only, the economic health of our communites would eventually return, and we would all benefit.  Local businesses would grow and would be able to hire more people at better wages, and a national healthcare system for small businesses would be inevitable

Think globally!  Act locally!


Walmart (4.00 / 1)
I tend to agree with the previous posters. What Walmart  does to small town America, intentional or not, is very ugly and a likely contribution to our current economic woes. However, and it's a big however, I have several very progressive friends who will occasionally shop at Walmart for reasons of their own. Those reasons include because there are no other "local" choices anymore... so Mission Accomplished Walmart, I guess, AND the fact that you can be both poor and progressive. I know we all understand that, but it bears stating the fact. Walmart is sometimes cheaper and progressives often don't take the jobs, the work, or the drive to the store that they wouldn't otherwise be caught dead in except for the other choices they have made that actually make them progressives.
So, no, I won't shop there. But I'm not going to judge people that do. We should have this conversation!

I think we need to ask ourselves this question, (4.00 / 1)
 "Are we no longer willing to sacrifice in order to make the world a better place?"  If Southern blacks had not been willing to walk, rather than ride the buses that said they should be in the back, where would they be now?  They took a stand, and said NO! Where would we be if students had not been willing to be tear gassed, and even shot, in order to end the war in Vietnam?

Is this what it has come to?  That we won't shop at Walmart "unless" some other store doesn't carry our favorite coffee, or Walmart is the only store with Wii. Or because we can save a few bucks.

Hey, I used to use the excuse that Walmart was the only store that carried my favorite oatmeal.

No more. No more.  


[ Parent ]
Premium Advertiser

blog advertising is good for you

Welcome!

( Home )
Menu

Click here to join!

Username:

Password:



Forget your username or password?


About
- About WVaBlue.com
- Send us news at wvablue@gmail.com
-  Subscribe in a reader

Advertisers


Support WVaBlue

Active Users
Currently 0 user(s) logged on.

Search




Advanced Search


Current CO2 level in the atmosphere

Proudly displaying the West Virginia Red, White, Blue, Green and Orange.

Join me at http://www.350.org


WVa Democrats
  • Sen. Jay Rockefeller
  • Sen. Joe Manchin III
  • Joe Manchin for Senate (2010/2012)
  • Rep. Nick Rahall (WV-03)
  • Secretary of State Natalie Tennant
  • Auditor Glen Gainer
  • Treasurer John Perdue
  • Agriculture Commissioner Gus Douglass
  • Attorney General Darrell V. McGraw
  • Senate President Earl Ray Tomblin, acting as Gov.
  • Declared Candidates
  • Jeff Kessler
  • John Perdue
  • Natalie Tennant
  • Earl Ray Tomblin
  • Rick Thompson

  • Copyright 2011 West Virginia Blue
    Site content may be used for any purpose without explicit permission unless otherwise specified.
    This site exists thanks to financial support from BlogPAC, dedicated volunteers and participation by members of this community. The views expressed at West Virginia Blue belong solely to their respective authors.
    Powered by: SoapBlox