West Virginia Blue
The Best Blogging Community in West Virginia
Democratic politics, progressive policies, the good life and free living in Wild, Wonderful West Virginia.
Big Daddy Sen. Robert C. Byrd

Sacrificing the Future

by: mtngirl2

Wed Apr 28, 2010 at 12:09:40 PM EDT


(Welcome to WVaBlue mtngirl2! Thanks for your post. - promoted by wvblueguy)

  I am writing this blog in response to the decision made by the West Virginia State Board of Education to provide in excess of 8 million dollars to Kanawha County to build a "School of the Future" while other projects in Southern West Virginia were ignored and Marsh Fork Elementary in the Coal River Valley of Raleigh County was offered only a portion of what would be needed to build a new school safe from the threats that the children in this school face daily. As a child I attended school in a coal town. Even though we had fantastic teachers who always did the best they could, the resources that were needed weren't always available.  Every day millions of dollars in coal passed through our town on trains and trucks, thanks to the work of the fathers of many of my classmates, but still we did not receive needed resources, adequate facilities or the same opportunities available to children who attended school in Princeton or Bluefield.  
As I have watched the events that have unfolded in the last year I can't help but see the similarities of these situations.  The fact that the children of  the coalfields are not given equal treatment by our state government is glaringly obvious.  We eventually received a new high school, built on an old strip mine site that was really unstable and not suitable for building.  We moved into a largely uncompleted school in the fall of 1983 and to my knowledge many of the completions were never made. Structural problems have appeared as a result of where the school was built.  It is now an elementary/middle school because the declining populations of the small communities forced an unwanted but accepted consolidation of the county's four smallest high schools and in the near future the middle school students will face the same consolidation and I suspect the elementary will soon follow.  
I have written all of this history to say that the children of the coalfields deserve better.  The communities where billions of dollars in coal are extracted by the blood and sweat of their citizens should be some of the wealthiest in this state. Instead the coal counties of Appalachia are the poorest in the nation.  The people who are subjected daily to coal dust, bad roads, unregulated coal companies, poverty and poor health conditions, should instead have the best kept roads (funded by the coal companies in my opinion), state of the art health facilities, libraries and schools along with the promise of bright futures for their children.  Instead children grow up thinking that they aren't important and that they can never have professional careers because they would have to leave their homes to find work.  They accept whatever insecure jobs are available from non-union coal mines or fast food establishments so that they can remain in the area where they grew up. This is oppression.  
The children of the coalfields of Appalachia deserve so much more than they are given.  The children of the Coal River Valley attend school in a 70 year old building that sits below the Shumate dam, which is one of the largest coal sludge impoundments in the nation.  Less than 400 feet away is a coal silo with another one being constructed, a coal haul road and a coal preparation plant.  They live with the daily threat of a break in the coal sludge dam that is situated directly above their school, now containing millions of gallons of thick, toxic coal sludge.  Add to all of that a large mountaintop removal coal mining site where blasting is occurring daily, adding to the already ever present coal dust and the instability of the Shumate Dam.  

It would seem to me that the number one project for a new school in West Virginia would be a new school for Marsh Fork Elementary followed closely by other inadequate schools in Southern West Virginia.  With the health and lives of so many children and staff at stake, how can a "School of the Future" for Kanawha County be so important that it has received the largest amount of the available funding?  More and more in West Virginia we are losing our communities.  For too many years the people of Southern West Virginia have sacrificed so that other areas (i.e. Charleston, Parkersburg, Morgantown) may prosper.  And, the people of Appalachia sacrifice every day for the comfort of America.  We, the people of Southern West Virginia must demand our share of the wealth that is extracted from our mountains and it should begin with investments in the future of the children of the coalfields.  

mtngirl2 :: Sacrificing the Future
Tags: , , , , (All Tags)
Print Friendly View Send As Email
response (4.00 / 4)
I most certainly didn't mean it to sound as though poor children anywhere didn't deserve new schools.  I did grow up in the coalfields and for along time now the schools in those areas have received less funding and available resources than schools in bigger towns and/or cities.  I do believe that poor children everywhere should have adequate educations, I was not in any way shape or form making a racial comment.  8.8 million dollars is ALOT of money to build a school.  The Marsh Fork School proposed is less than 6 million.  Is it fair that children, of any economic background, be given a school with more resources, technology and innovation than another school in our state designed for the same age children? The families in Marsh Fork really just want a safe school for their children.  It has very little to do with the resources and such that I pointed out.  It has more to do with their health and safety.  There really is a huge sludge dam sitting above the school, larger than the one that burst and caused the Buffalo Creek disaster in 1972, and there is a mountaintop removal site where they are blasting daily, near the sludge dam.  That puts more than just the children of the school in danger but they are the first building in its path if it burst.  They also breathe coaldust daily.  That causes respiratory issues and other health problems.  I hope that this makes clearer my view about the situation.  I am an advocate for poor children no matter where they live, but I have personal ties to the children in the coalfields.  
Thank you.

I'm going to wade into this discussion (4.00 / 5)
and look at the Marsh Fork School situation from a different angle.  Let's get to the basic issue: the entire WV educational system doesn't have enough money because too much of the profit from our mineral resources leaves the state and goes into the pockets of executives, stockholders and banks elsewhere.  That is a fundamental fact of life in our state.

The entity that should be paying the entire cost of a new Marsh Fork School is Massey Energy, because they have done the most to put students there in danger.

The WV School Building Authority, which was created during the Caperton administration, has as its basic mission to consolidate WV's county school systems of the backs of rural students.  Calhoun County was the SBA's very first victim.  The schools that were closed here were both elementary schools, and since then there have been 6 year olds traveling 1 1/2 hours to school, each way, every day.

It makes no sense to talk about one area being favored over another, because all poor kids get screwed by the current WV school construction system.  Most major urban school systems in the US have decided to break their larger schools into smaller community schools.  In WV, we are still covering up destruction of community schools with blather about "schools of the future" and "21st century schools".

The children at Marsh Fork deserve a new school.  Instead of forcing counties to provide matching funding or issuing bonds, why doesn't the Legislature increase the severance tax on coal with the increase dedicated to building new schools?

20 years ago, the tax assessor in Webster County decided to tax coal reserves at their true value, which would have poured millions of dollars into Webster County schools.  The State Tax Department joined in with the coal companies to sue the assessor in a case that went all the way to the US Supreme Court, where the fair tax assessment was ruled illegal.

The problem is the theft of WV resources, not who gets to pick up the crumbs that fall off the table.


Good points here.... (4.00 / 4)
I agree whole-heartedly with this take on the situation.  The counties where coal is extracted are the poorest in the nation.  There is definitely something wrong with that.  If I remember correctly, not wanting to do massive research to find this, but the WV Legislature actually came up with a bill that would raise the severance tax that is paid to cities like Whitesville and others where the most coal is taken from.  It wasn't written correctly because the coal severence taxes changed amounts and the bill didn't coincide with the new official amounts, so therefore even though it passed both the WV House and Senate it never made it to the Governor's desk because it was written incorrectly.  That is what I remember, maybe someone else has some information other than mine on that situation.  But I am sure that is not what the Coal Companies nor those officials in their pockets wanted, so maybe it died a convenient death for them.  
The public education system fails in so many ways.  West Virginia will be the last to admit those failures I am afraid.  I know lots and lots of teachers who agree with me on this point.  They are no longer free to teach.  Large schools spell failure for so many kids.  Bigger is not better in education.  
Thank you for your comments.  This is my first blog on WVABLUE.

[ Parent ]
I strongly suspect that bill was sandbagged by Steve Kominar (D-Mingo) (4.00 / 1)
And it actually made it to Manchin's desk, but he rejected it on a technicality. He could have signed it and resolved the technicality later, but the upshot is that they don't want families living in the coalfields to have their fair share. Simply because that would goes against the coal operators' master plan to either drive everyone off their precious coal, or else kill them all off slowly by poisonig them to death.

If you think Kominar isn't in the coal operator's pocket, just read what he and his sidekick from Boone County had to say at about reclamation at this link.

Mtngirl2, you mentioned the basic unfairness of our educational system, particularly regarding the coalpatch school districts. That's been going on for a long long time.  The landmark Recht Decision as supposed to have equalled that situation out, but it hasn't even come close, thanks to our coal-powered statehouse.

For a good overview, check this out, and then ask yourself why in the hell the 4 out of 5 school districts that have had to be taken over by the state are all in the southern coal fields. Mingo TWICE!



[ Parent ]
Premium Advertiser

blog advertising is good for you

Welcome!

( Home )
Menu

Click here to join!

Username:

Password:



Forget your username or password?


About
- About WVaBlue.com
- Send us news at wvablue@gmail.com
-  Subscribe in a reader

Advertisers


Support WVaBlue

Active Users
Currently 0 user(s) logged on.

Search




Advanced Search


Current CO2 level in the atmosphere

Proudly displaying the West Virginia Red, White, Blue, Green and Orange.

Join me at http://www.350.org


WVa Democrats
  • Sen. Jay Rockefeller
  • Sen. Joe Manchin III
  • Joe Manchin for Senate (2010/2012)
  • Rep. Nick Rahall (WV-03)
  • Secretary of State Natalie Tennant
  • Auditor Glen Gainer
  • Treasurer John Perdue
  • Agriculture Commissioner Gus Douglass
  • Attorney General Darrell V. McGraw
  • Senate President Earl Ray Tomblin, acting as Gov.
  • Declared Candidates
  • Jeff Kessler
  • John Perdue
  • Natalie Tennant
  • Earl Ray Tomblin
  • Rick Thompson

  • Copyright 2011 West Virginia Blue
    Site content may be used for any purpose without explicit permission unless otherwise specified.
    This site exists thanks to financial support from BlogPAC, dedicated volunteers and participation by members of this community. The views expressed at West Virginia Blue belong solely to their respective authors.
    Powered by: SoapBlox