West Virginia Blue
The Best Blogging Community in West Virginia
Democratic politics, progressive policies, the good life and free living in Wild, Wonderful West Virginia.
Big Daddy Sen. Robert C. Byrd

Missing Big Daddy Byrd

by: Carnacki

Sat Jan 15, 2011 at 09:31:00 AM EST


Posted by Carnacki

Robert C. ByrdSen. Robert C. Byrd on Coal Must Embrace the Future (often called his "Honest Broker" speech):

...West Virginia's elected officials are rightly concerned about jobs and the economic impact on local communities.  I share those concerns.  But the time has come to have an open and honest dialogue about coal's future in West Virginia.

Let's speak the truth. The most important factor in maintaining coal-related jobs is demand for coal. Scapegoating and stoking fear among workers over the permitting process is counter-productive.

...

West Virginians may demonstrate anger toward the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) over mountaintop removal mining, but we risk the very probable consequence of shouting ourselves out of any productive dialogue with EPA and our adversaries in the Congress.

...

We can have a part in shaping energy policy, but we must be honest brokers if we have any prayer of influencing coal policy on looming issues important to the future of coal like hazardous air pollutants, climate change, and federal dollars for investments in clean coal technology.

Acting Gov. Earl Ray Tomblin, announcing a pro-coal rally:

"We must stand up and show federal
regulators that we will not retreat from their unfair actions. We will continue the fight not just for the Spruce Number One mine but for every
coal miner, coal company and for our way of life."

Sen. Joe Manchin:

"Today's EPA decision is not just fundamentally wrong," he said. "It is an unprecedented act by the federal government that will cost our state and our nation even more jobs during the worst recession in this country's history.

"While the EPA decision hurts West Virginia today, it has negative ramifications for every state in our nation, and I strongly urge every senator and every member of Congress to voice their opposition."

Sen. Jay Rockefeller:

I am writing to express my outrage with the Environmental Protection Agency's (EPA) decision to veto a rigorously reviewed and lawfully issued permit at the Spruce Number 1 Mine in Logan County, West Virginia.  This action not only affects this specific permit, but needlessly throws other permits into a sea of uncertainty at a time of great economic distress.

Apparently they West Virginians who don't want poisoned wells or to live in fear of flash floods or having to live surrounded by the remains of a destroyed mountain don't deserve leaders fighting for them even though the EPA did exactly what the coal supporters wanted in forming a long review process based on scientific evidence.

Tomblin, Manchin, and Rockefeller are doing exactly what Byrd warned against.

Not an honest broker in the bunch.

Carnacki :: Missing Big Daddy Byrd
Tags: , , , , , (All Tags)
Print Friendly View Send As Email

how 'bout some fact-based leadership? (4.00 / 4)
Ken Ward, Jr. asked a crucial question yesterday, The politics of the Spruce Mine: Do facts matter?

Step one for someone stepping up to fill Sen. Byrd's legacy is acknowledging facts.

This argument is built on the assumption, declared by Sen. Manchin at his press conference, that:

This permit had gone through the proper channels ... It had cleared at every aspect.

That sure sounds good. And when you hear it repeated by every media outlet in the state, you can easily be convinced that this is some terribly frightening action by those nasty folks at EPA.

There's just one problem ... it's not true.

First of all, the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency never signed off on this permit. Never.

In fact, if you read yesterday's Final Determination document issued by EPA, you learn that agency officials had raised questions about the Spruce Mine from the very beginning ... See the history, starting on page 18. It's especially important to note that the position taken by EPA on the Spruce Mine prior to the current veto proceeding was a June 2006 letter in which Bush administration EPA officials commented on the Corps' draft study of the permit's environmental impacts.

Ken's entire post is well worth reading... it lays out the history of the Spruce Mine permit process better than I've seen anywhere else. He concludes:

Judge Chambers has never ruled on the Spruce Mine. Over the last year or more, he's been waiting for EPA to go through its review and potential veto of the permit. Now that's been completed, and there's an opportunity for both sides to have their say and get a ruling.

So when politicians say the Spruce Mine has crossed every hurdle, they're just wrong.

Remember, this past year the EPA worked with other mining companies to find ways to get the majority of coal with substantially environmental impact than original permit request. Best I can tell, Mingo Logan Coal Company has decided it is unwilling to work with the EPA in a similar way.

Of course, one huge challenge for Spurce Mine may be the Little Coal River watershed is already suffering from such major cumulative impact it may well be impossible to make any additional surface disruption without adverse impact.

In either case, West Virginians deserve fact-based leadership, not demagogy.


More lies and smoke from (4.00 / 2)
the acting governor...how soon they forget the wise words of our beloved Sen Byrd, I do believe he's rolling in his grave...Great post Carnacki, great comment Clem....have we exposed the Blair Mountain connection in all this?  From what I understand part of the Spruce Mine footprint (sic) is the historical Blair Mountain which was de-listed by our former Gov Manchini before he left office last year.  The plot thickens...

Premium Advertiser

blog advertising is good for you

Welcome!

( Home )
Menu

Click here to join!

Username:

Password:



Forget your username or password?


About
- About WVaBlue.com
- Send us news at wvablue@gmail.com
-  Subscribe in a reader

Advertisers


Support WVaBlue

Active Users
Currently 0 user(s) logged on.

Search




Advanced Search


Current CO2 level in the atmosphere

Proudly displaying the West Virginia Red, White, Blue, Green and Orange.

Join me at http://www.350.org


WVa Democrats
  • Sen. Jay Rockefeller
  • Sen. Joe Manchin III
  • Joe Manchin for Senate (2010/2012)
  • Rep. Nick Rahall (WV-03)
  • Secretary of State Natalie Tennant
  • Auditor Glen Gainer
  • Treasurer John Perdue
  • Agriculture Commissioner Gus Douglass
  • Attorney General Darrell V. McGraw
  • Senate President Earl Ray Tomblin, acting as Gov.
  • Declared Candidates
  • Jeff Kessler
  • John Perdue
  • Natalie Tennant
  • Earl Ray Tomblin
  • Rick Thompson

  • Copyright 2011 West Virginia Blue
    Site content may be used for any purpose without explicit permission unless otherwise specified.
    This site exists thanks to financial support from BlogPAC, dedicated volunteers and participation by members of this community. The views expressed at West Virginia Blue belong solely to their respective authors.
    Powered by: SoapBlox